First Nation sues radiologist for performing MRI scan of liver without consent


A previous version of this article contained an image provided by Getty Images and contained inaccurate caption information that the image did not belong to Chief Andrea Paul. She is Denning Bernard. We have removed the image from this article.

Dozens of First Nations have filed a lawsuit against two Canadian radiologists, accusing them of performing MRI scans without consent as part of a secret scientific study of their livers.

According to the lawsuit, 59 members In 2017 and 2018, the Pictou Landing First Nation underwent invasive MRI scans for research purposes without their knowledge. The complaint was first filed with the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia in June 2020 and was certified as a class-action lawsuit this month.

In the lawsuit, the plaintiffs cite Canada’s dark history of non-consensual experiments on Aboriginal people, which they say is motivated by racism.

According to the claim, lead plaintiff Andrea Paul, a principal at Pictou Landing, participated in a consensual MRI scan in March 2017 as part of a medical research project conducted by the Canadian Alliance for Healthy Minds at a research facility in Nova Scotia, Halifax. Save the province.

The lawsuit alleges that instead of exiting the MRI machine after the scan, Paul was inadvertently left in the scanner as part of a second, separate study looking at liver disease in Aboriginal people.

“Chief Andrea was unaware of the Aboriginal research and had no idea she was participating in it. Data generated by the MRI scan as she lay in the claustrophobic MRI room holding her breath and wincing from the loud crashing sounds around her Intimate medical information about her body was revealed without her knowledge or consent,” the lawsuit states. “She was singled out for one reason – she’s a Mi’kmaw.”

The lawsuit names radiologists Robert Miller and Sharon Clark as defendants, accusing them of conducting separate MRI studies. Based on the scans, Miller and Clark later presented their results at a conference in Halifax and wrote an unpublished research paper titled, “Research on Liver Disease among Aboriginal Peoples in Atlantic Canada,” the lawsuit alleges. Magnetic Resonance Imaging Discovery.”

See also  Shocking photos of Haiti protests and gang-related violence

Attorneys representing Miller and Clark declined to comment when contacted by The Washington Post. Lawyers representing the plaintiffs did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Paul learned about another study in June 2018, after which dozens of members of the Pictou Landing First Nations community also became aware that their livers had been harvested without their consent in 2017 and 2018, the lawsuit states. studied.

“Understand the long history of cruel medical experimentation on Canada’s Aboriginal people, including starvation studies on children, and learn that research protocols have been developed to ensure consent from Aboriginal people to participate in health research and to affirm the rights of Aboriginal people to possess and use medicines,” the lawsuit states. , Chief Andrea, who controls Aboriginal research data, feels powerless, vulnerable and discriminated against because she is Mi’kmaw.

According to the website of the plaintiff’s attorney,participants didn’t get scan results – even though they “discovered a health problem that required treatment.”

The plaintiff is seeking damages from the defendants and claims from the defendants for invasion of privacy, false imprisonment, assault and battery, negligence, breach of trust and fiduciary duty, and breach of contract. The lawsuit will next go to a common issues trial, attorneys said, but no date has been set.

What to know about Canadian residential schools and unmarked graves found nearby

In recent years, Canada has embarked on a national reckoning with its treatment of its Indigenous people, including observing National Truth and Reconciliation Day to honor Indigenous victims and survivors of Canada’s government-funded and Catholic Church-run residential school system.

Nearly 150,000 Aboriginal children Between the 19th century and the late 1990s, they were sent to boarding schools for assimilation. In 2021, the remains of 215 Aboriginal children were discovered in unmarked graves near a residential school in British Columbia.

See also  Israel's Knesset backs Netanyahu, rejects push for 'unilateral' recognition of Palestinian state

In schools, researchers are subjecting children to bizarre, invasive and cruel experiments — many of which were unknown to the Canadian public until recently.

50 children at the Brandon Indian Residential School in Brandon, Manitoba, 1940s tested Seeking evidence for extrasensory perception or a “sixth sense” among Aboriginal people.

In 2013, a researcher revealed that beginning in 1942, researchers conducted “nutritional” experiments on Aboriginal children for nearly a decade. These experiments deprive children of nutrients in the name of science and allow conditions of virtual starvation to continue.

The king broke his promise to the native peoples. It may now owe billions of dollars.

Prominent institutions in the United States are also grappling with a history of mistreatment of indigenous peoples and artifacts during scientific research, including many violations that have only recently come to light.

last year, “Washington Post” report The Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History contains more than 30,700 human remains, mostly taken from cemeteries, battlefields, morgues, and hospitals around the world during the 19th and 20th centuries; among them are 255 human brains, mostly from black, Aboriginal and other people of color to further research on now-debunked theories of racial disparity.

Uncovering the Smithsonian’s “Racial Brain Collection”

in January, The American Museum of Natural History in New York announced It would close two halls dedicated to North American indigenous cultures while it reviews whether museums need consent to display the artifacts. Last year, Interior Secretary Deb Haaland tightened federal regulations requiring museums and federal agencies to identify stolen sacred objects and return them to their respective cultural groups.

Source link

By Ali Raza

I am a dedicated and skilled News Content Writer with a passion for delivering accurate and engaging stories to a diverse audience. With a solid background in journalism and a keen eye for detail, I bring a commitment to excellence and a deep understanding of the evolving media landscape.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *